| Year | Elders | |||
| 2007 | Don | Keis | 7-2 | 57.69% |
| 2006 | Don | Keis | 9-0 | 70.79% |
| 2005 | Don | Keis | 8-1 | 70.56% |
| 2004 | Ray | Santana | 9-1 | 71.07% |
| 2003 | Tom | Munoz | 9-2 | 61.11% |
| 2002 | Ray | Santana | 6-0 | 69.51% |
| 2001 | Leldon | Day | 8-1 | 68.10% |
| 2000 | Ray | Santana | 9-0 | 69.20% |
| 1999 | Ray | Santana | 9-0 | 79.80% |
| 1998 | Ray | Santana | 7-0 | 77.30% |
| 1997 | Ray | Santana | 7-0 | 77.20% |
| 1996 | Ray | Santana | 6-0 | 73.90% |
| 1995 | Ray | Santana | 9-0 | 75.40% |
| 1994 | Ray | Santana | 8-0 | 68.90% |
| 1993 | Ray | Santana | 7-0 | 74.30% |
| 1992 | Jack | Stewart | 6-1 | 61.40% |
| 1991 | Irwin | Miller | 3-0 | 55.00% |
| 1990 | Herb | Rushing | 6-0 | 62.50% |
| 1989 | Herb | Rushing | 6-1 | 56.50% |